| Jill Taylor | Swimming | 1974 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Brent Cutcliffe | Badminton | 1974 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Donna Sears | Golf | 1974 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Paul Nogler | Track & Field | 1974 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Nancy White | Speed Skating | 1975 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Mike Jenkins | Boxing | 1975 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Donna Sears | Golf | 1975 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| David Lundrigan | Track & Field | 1975 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Dr. Wen MacDonald Rink | Curling | 1975 | Team - est. 1975 |
| David MacNeill | Parasport | 1975 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Kellye Crockett | Table Tennis | 1976 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Brent Cutcliffe | Badminton | 1976 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Jill Taylor | Swimming | 1976 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Andrew Walker | Track & Field | 1976 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Bill Jenkins Rink | Curling | 1976 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Clifford Gillis | Hockey | 1976 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| G.W. Pineau | Figure Skating | 1976 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Maxine Connors | Swimming | 1976 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Carol Moore | Synchronized Swim | 1977 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Ed Suen | Table Tennis | 1977 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kellye Crockett | Table Tennis | 1977 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Ian “Tex” MacDonald | Softball | 1977 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| UPEI Panthers | Basketball | 1977 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Myron Weeks | Volleyball | 1977 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Clair Sudsbury | Hockey | 1977 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Bill Jenkins Curling Rink | Curling | 1977 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Robert Barwise | Shooting | 1977 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Petra de Lima | Tennis | 1978 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Roland Young | Boxing | 1978 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Nancy White | Speed Skating | 1978 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Richard Vaive | Hockey | 1978 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Charlottetown DB&J Eagles Junior A | Hockey | 1978 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Bruce Norton | Soccer | 1978 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Dr. Athol Roberts | Equestrian | 1978 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Lisa Devine | Racquetball | 1979 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Peter Surette | Figure Skating | 1979 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Nancy White | Speed Skating | 1979 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Hubert “Socky” MacDonald | Football/Softball | 1979 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Sherwood/Parkdale Metros Junior A | Hockey | 1979 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Merritt Crockett | Table Tennis | 1979 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Tom Wallis | Soccer | 1979 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Lisa Devine | Racquetball | 1980 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Tom Hilton | Swimming | 1980 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Donna Phillips | Field Hockey | 1980 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Paul Nogler | Racquetball | 1980 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| John Fortier Mixed Rink | Curling | 1980 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Jim Rand | Gymnastics & Bill Oehlke - Wrestling | 1980 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Don Fitzpatrick | Softball | 1980 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Callie MacPhail | Hockey & Softball | 1980 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Margie Savidant | Disabled Sport | 1981 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Champion Butler | Wrestling | 1981 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Donna Phillips | Field Hockey | 1981 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Kevin O’Brien | Speed Skating | 1981 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Charlottetown Islanders Intermediate | Hockey | 1981 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Angus Carroll | Hockey | 1981 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Ron Atkinson | Shooting | 1981 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Mitch Murphy | Hockey/Softball | 1981 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Lisa Devine | Racquetball | 1982 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| George Collard | Racquetball | 1982 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Sheila MacQuarrie | Shooting | 1982 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Paul Nogler | Racquetball | 1982 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Bill Merklinger Mixed Rink | Curling | 1982 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Ernie Dunsford | Softball | 1982 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Bob Perry | Parasport | 1982 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Gerard Gallant | Hockey/Softball | 1982 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Lisa Devine | Racquetball | 1983 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Andy Fitzpatrick | Racquetball | 1983 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Sheila MacQuarrie | Shooting | 1983 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Paul Nogler | Racquetball | 1983 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| UPEI Panthers | Soccer | 1983 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Barbara Phillips | Field Hockey | 1983 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Heather MacGregor | Equestrian | 1983 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Anna Pendergast | Basketball | 1983 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Sheila MacQuarrie | Shooting | 1983 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Michelle Ives | Basketball/Field Hockey | 1983 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Larry Gaudet | Baseball/Hockey | 1983 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Katherine Josey | Swimming | 1984 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jeff Ready | Golf | 1984 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kathryn MacDougall | Field Hockey | 1984 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Patrick Griffin | Wheelchair Basketball | 1984 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Charlottetown Islanders Intermediate | Hockey | 1984 | Team - est. 1975 |
| UPEI Panthers | Soccer | 1984 | Team - est. 1975 |
| David Campbell | Swimming | 1984 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Sharon Knox | Curling | 1984 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Cathy Hendricken | Broomball/Softball | 1984 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Albert Roche | Baseball/Hockey | 1984 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Katherine Josey | Swimming | 1985 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Tyler Larter | Hockey | 1985 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kathryn MacDougall | Field Hockey | 1985 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Robert C. Barwise | Shooting | 1985 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kent Scales Junior Rink | Curling | 1985 | Team - est. 1975 |
| George Morrison | Basketball | 1985 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Vernon Frizzell | Figure Skating | 1985 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Tracy MacEachern | Basketball/Field Hockey | 1985 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Phillip Gorveatt | Baseball/Curling | 1985 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Susan MacMillan | Swimming | 1986 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Tyler Larter | Hockey | 1986 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kathryn MacDougall | Field Hockey | 1986 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Glen Collard | Racquetball | 1986 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Summerside Capitol Twins | Softball | 1986 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Shane Turner & Fred Younker | Hockey | 1986 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Cheryl Thow | Curling | 1986 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Tracy MacEachern | Basketball/Field Hockey | 1986 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Scott Bridges | Hockey/Softball | 1986 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Shehla Chishti | Table Tennis | 1987 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jay Nogler | Racquetball | 1987 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Anna Pendergast-Stammberger | Basketball | 1987 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Julius Rethy | Softball | 1987 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Peter Gallant Mixed Rink | Curling | 1987 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Harvey Inman | Softball | 1987 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| John Blakney | Figure Skating | 1987 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Tracy MacEachern | Basketball/Field Hockey | 1987 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Andrew Bartlett | Hockey/Soccer | 1987 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Amy MacFarlane | Table Tennis | 1988 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Scott Chandler | Gymnastics | 1988 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Lorie Kane | Golf | 1988 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Ron Frid | Track & Field | 1988 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| UPEI Panthers Women’s | Basketball | 1988 | Team - est. 1975 |
| David MacNeill | Basketball | 1988 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Clair Sudsbury | Hockey | 1988 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Dean Thibodeau | Basketball/Volleyball | 1988 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Contessa Scott | Goalball | 1989 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Steven Watts | Boxing | 1989 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Barbara McNeill | Swimming | 1989 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Dean Kelly | Wrestling | 1989 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Deborah MacMurdo | Figure Skating | 1989 | Officials - 1989 |
| Hemphill Pontiac Western Capitals | Hockey | 1989 | Team - est. 1975 |
| David Cameron | Hockey | 1989 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Ron Rice | Baseball | 1989 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Marla Callaghan | Gymnastics/ Golf | 1989 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Ian Power | Baseball/Curling | 1989 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Jana Hughes | Swimming | 1990 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Scott Chandler | Gymnastics | 1990 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Lorie Kane | Golf | 1990 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Richard Little | Hockey | 1990 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Stan Porter | Baseball | 1990 | Officials - 1989 |
| Shehla Chishti & Amy MacFarlane | Table Tennis | 1990 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Bill MacMillan | Hockey | 1990 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Lea Rand | Gymnastics | 1990 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Heather Morrison | Field Hockey/ Athletics | 1990 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Mark Corrigan | Basketball/Softball | 1990 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Lindsay Robb | Equestrian | 1991 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Steven Watts | Boxing | 1991 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Lorie Kane | Golf | 1991 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Scott Morrison | Wheelchair Athletics | 1991 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Allan Affleck | Hockey | 1991 | Officials - 1989 |
| PEI Armour Fence Islanders | Hockey | 1991 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Lynne McLeod | Rhythmic Gymnastics | 1991 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Jim Newson | Equestrian | 1991 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Kelly Gaudet | Figure Skating/Athletics | 1991 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| John Rombough | Nordic Skiing/Athletics | 1991 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Cherie Hansen | Golf | 1992 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Scott Chandler | Gymnastics | 1992 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Lorie Kane | Golf | 1992 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Shane MacEachern | Hockey | 1992 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Heather Howatt | Figure Skating | 1992 | Officials - 1989 |
| PEI Stars | Special Olympics Floor Hockey | 1992 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Peter Bolo | Volleyball | 1992 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Terry Allen | Soccer | 1992 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Jennifer Johnston | Basketball/volleyball/softball | 1992 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Sean Fraser | Cycling/Nordic Skiing | 1992 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Jennifer Le | Badminton | 1993 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Sean Fraser | Cross Country Skiing | 1993 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Julie Carver | Shooting | 1993 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Dean Thibodeau | Basketball | 1993 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Brian Carragher | Hockey | 1993 | Officials - 1989 |
| Canada Games Men’s | Softball | 1993 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Kevin Quinn | Softball | 1993 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Najam Chishti | Table Tennis | 1993 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| David “Eli” MacEachern | Bobsleigh | 1993 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Paul Wright | Nordic Skiing/Athletics | 1993 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Krista Cameron | Curling | 1994 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Greg Arsenault | Wrestling | 1994 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Contessa Scott | Goalball | 1994 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jason MacDonald | Hockey | 1994 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Deborah MacMurdo | Figure Skating | 1994 | Officials - 1989 |
| PEI Women’s Team | Goalball | 1994 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Chris Annett | Basketball | 1994 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Lea Rand | Gymnastics | 1994 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Jim Hogan | Multiple Sports | 1994 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Susannah Rodgers | Biathlon/Canoeing | 1994 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Kara Grant | Equestrian | 1995 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Joe Gallant | Boxing | 1995 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Cherie Hansen | Golf | 1995 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| David Ling | Hockey | 1995 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Trent Birt | Hockey | 1995 | Officials - 1989 |
| Peter MacDonald Mixed Rink | Curling | 1995 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Lloyd MacCallum | Curling | 1995 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Linda Durling | Tennis | 1995 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Bill Ledwell | Multiple Sports/Media | 1995 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Bradley Johnston | Triathlon | 1995 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Bobbie Dawson | Synchronized Swim | 1996 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Andrew Bryenton | Bowling | 1996 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Karen Vos | Basketball | 1996 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Josh Ballem | Swimming | 1996 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Norman Beck | Hockey | 1996 | Officials - 1989 |
| Charlottetown Abbies U15 Girls | Soccer | 1996 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Dave Campbell | Swimming | 1996 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Deborah Gee | Synchronized Swimming | 1996 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Tom Wallis | Soccer | 1996 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Jennifer Arbing | Curling | 1996 | Fair Play - (1996-2003) |
| Krista Connolly | Basketball/Volleyball | 1996 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Bradley Johnston | Triathlon | 1996 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Bradley Johnston | Triathlon | 1996 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Kara Grant | Equestrian | 1997 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Ryan Kowalski | Baseball | 1997 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Tracy McGee | Field Hockey | 1997 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Steve Edmonds | Judo | 1997 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Mike Connolly | Soccer | 1997 | Officials - 1989 |
| Summerside Western Capitals | Hockey | 1997 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Roger Ahern | Softball | 1997 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Ron Rice | Baseball | 1997 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Charlie Ryan | Baseball | 1997 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Saba Chishti | Table Tennis | 1997 | Fair Play - (1996-2003) |
| Bradley Johnson | Triathlon | 1997 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Monica Bradley | Figure Skating | 1998 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jonathan Vos | Soccer | 1998 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kara Grant | Pentathlon | 1998 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Glen Miller | Soccer | 1998 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Thane Arsenault | Hockey | 1998 | Officials - 1989 |
| Suzanne Gaudet Rink | Curling | 1998 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Sherry White | Speed Skating | 1998 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Dawn MacFadyen | Curling | 1998 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Cecil MacPhail | Softball | 1998 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Stefanie Richard | Curling | 1998 | Fair Play - (1996-2003) |
| David “Eli” MacEachern | Bobsleigh | 1998 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Heather Moyse | Athletics/Rugby | 1998 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Andrew Bryenton | Baseball/Bowling | 1998 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Natalie Burke | Judo | 1999 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Justin Chiasson | Boxing | 1999 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kara Grant | Pentathlon | 1999 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Brad Richards | Hockey | 1999 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Wilfred Wright | Badminton | 1999 | Officials - 1989 |
| Charlottetown Abbies Junior | Hockey | 1999 | Team - est. 1975 |
| John MacLean | Karate | 1999 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Jean Eldershaw | Figure Skating | 1999 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Mike Kelly | Hockey | 1999 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Cory Jay | Cycling | 1999 | Fair Play - (1996-2003) |
| Kara Grant | Pentathlon | 1999 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Kara Grant | Pentathlon | 1999 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Justin Rowe | Badminton/Soccer | 1999 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Kelly Trainor | Bowling | 2000 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Drew MacIntyre | Hockey | 2000 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Contessa Scott | Goalball | 2000 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Steve Edmonds | Judo | 2000 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Jim Lynn | Baseball | 2000 | Officials - 1989 |
| PEI Youth Bowling Challenge | Bowling | 2000 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Frank MacIntyre | Goalball | 2000 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| George Morrison | Baseball | 2000 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Barney Bree | Swimming | 2000 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Suzanne Gaudet Rink | Curling | 2000 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Heather Moyse | Rugby/Athletics | 2000 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics/Soccer | 2000 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Mark Gregory | Hockey/Table Tennis | 2000 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Kelly Higgins | Curling | 2001 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Morgan Carlile | Baseball | 2001 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Suzanne Gaudet | Curling | 2001 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Steve Edmonds | Judo | 2001 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Najam Chishti | Table Tennis | 2001 | Officials - 1989 |
| Suzanne Gaudet Rink | Curling | 2001 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Paul Power | Curling | 2001 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Cecil Villard | Special Olympics | 2001 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Gerald Keough | Multiple Sports | 2001 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Suzanne Gaudet Rink | Curling | 2001 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Heather Ayles | Cycling/Powerlifting | 2001 | All-Around Female - (1983-2002) |
| Jeff Ellis | Hockey/Soccer | 2001 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2002 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Suzanne Gaudet | Curling | 2002 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Steve Edmonds | Judo | 2002 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Najam Chishti | Table Tennis | 2002 | Officials - 1989 |
| Suzanne Gaudet Rink | Curling | 2002 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Lewis Page | Soccer | 2002 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Sharon Knox | Curling | 2002 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Alicia Wilbert | Judo | 2003 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Matthew Lemon | Gymnastics | 2003 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Suzanne Gaudet | Curling | 2003 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Tom Nicholls | Powerlifting | 2003 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Jim Lynn | Baseball | 2003 | Officials - 1989 |
| UPEI Panthers Men’s | Basketball | 2003 | Team - est. 1975 |
| John Wilbert | Judo | 2003 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Debbie MacMurdo | Figure Skating | 2003 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Myron Weeks | Volleyball | 2003 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Amanda Bulman | Cross Country Ski | 2003 | Fair Play - (1996-2003) |
| Paul Wright | Cross Country Ski/Athletics | 2003 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Megan MacLellan | Boxing | 2004 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Morgan Carlile | Baseball | 2004 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Contessa Scott | Goalball | 2004 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jarrod Ballem | Swimming | 2004 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Heather Moyse | Rugby | 2004 | Intercollegiate Female - est. 2004 |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2004 | Intercollegiate Male - est . 2004 |
| Keith Tanton | Athletics | 2004 | Masters - est. 2004 |
| Kent Walker | Baseball | 2004 | Officials - 1989 |
| UPEI Panthers Women’s | Soccer | 2004 | Team - est. 1975 |
| UPEI Panthers Women’s | Soccer | 2004 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Frank MacIntyre | Goalball | 2004 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Daphne Andrews | Soccer | 2004 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Lothar Zimmermann | Fencing | 2004 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Todd Gregory | Table Tennis, Hockey | 2004 | All-Around Male (1980-2004) |
| Tessa Roche | Soccer | 2005 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Patrick Knox | Judo/Wrestling | 2005 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Heather Moyse | Rugby/Bobsleigh | 2005 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2005 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Amy Connolly | Soccer | 2005 | Intercollegiate Female - est. 2004 |
| Ryan Anstey | Soccer | 2005 | Intercollegiate Male - est . 2004 |
| Tom Nicholls | Powerlifting | 2005 | Masters - est. 2004 |
| Mike Connolly | Soccer | 2005 | Officials - 1989 |
| Eliot River Piazza Joe’s | Soccer | 2005 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Colin MacAdam | Athletics | 2005 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Stephen Marchbank | Basketball | 2005 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Clair Sudsbury | Hockey/Hall of Fame | 2005 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Heather Moyse | Bobsleigh | 2005 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Ashley MacIntyre | Rugby | 2006 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Logan MacMillan | Hockey | 2006 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Heather Moyse | Rugby/Bobsleigh | 2006 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jeff Ellsworth | Softball | 2006 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Angela Drane | Golf | 2006 | Intercollegiate Female - est. 2004 |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2006 | Intercollegiate Male - est . 2004 |
| Shawn McCardle | Running | 2006 | Masters - est. 2004 |
| Jeff MacRae | Gymnastics | 2006 | Officials - 1989 |
| Team PEI | Goalball | 2006 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Gardiner MacDougall | Hockey | 2006 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Glenn Holmes | Speed Skating | 2006 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Marilyn Sutherland | Curling/Golf | 2006 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Alicia Wilbert | Judo | 2007 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Patrick Knox | Judo/Wrestling | 2007 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kara Grant | Pentathlon | 2007 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jarrod Ballem | Swimming | 2007 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kristina Weatherbie | Soccer | 2007 | Intercollegiate Female - est. 2004 |
| Darryl Boyce | Hockey | 2007 | Intercollegiate Male - est . 2004 |
| Paul Wright | Nordic Ski | 2007 | Masters - est. 2004 |
| Joe Ryan | Volleyball | 2007 | Officials - 1989 |
| Brett Gallant Rink | Curling | 2007 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Gardiner MacDougall | Hockey | 2007 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Barb Carmichael | Field Hockey | 2007 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| John Wilbert | Judo | 2007 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Stephanie Ramsay | Hockey | 2008 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Brandon Gormley | Hockey | 2008 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Kara Grant | Pentathlon | 2008 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2008 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Ashley MacDonald | Rugby | 2008 | Intercollegiate Female - est. 2004 |
| Paul Craig | Soccer | 2008 | Intercollegiate Male - est . 2004 |
| Collin Affleck | Karate | 2008 | Masters - est. 2004 |
| Justine Lewis | Soccer | 2008 | Officials - 1989 |
| Avondale Islanders | Soccer | 2008 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Jim Rand | Gymnastics | 2008 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Peter Howatt | Special Olympics | 2008 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Frank and Margaret Parslow | Badminton | 2008 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2008 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Veronica Keefe | Wrestling | 2009 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Matthieu D’Amour | Gymnastics | 2009 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Katie Baker | Field Hockey | 2009 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2009 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Ashley MacDonald | Rugby | 2009 | Intercollegiate Female - est. 2004 |
| Kurt McCormack | Athletics | 2009 | Intercollegiate Male - est . 2004 |
| Jen Nicholson | Running | 2009 | Masters - est. 2004 |
| Jeff MacRae | Gymnastics | 2009 | Officials - 1989 |
| Brett Gallant Rink | Curling | 2009 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Lewis Page | Soccer | 2009 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Mark Bowlan | Cycling | 2009 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Joe Spriet | Canada Games Host Society | 2009 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Brett Gallant Rink | Curling | 2009 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
| Ryan Drum | Kickboxing | 2010 | Junior Female - est. 1974 |
| Brandon Gormley | Hockey | 2010 | Junior Male - est. 1974 |
| Heather Moyse | Bobsleigh/Rugby | 2010 | Senior Female - est. 1974 |
| Jared Connaughton | Athletics | 2010 | Senior Male - est. 1974 |
| Ashley MacDonald | Rugby | 2010 | Intercollegiate Female - est. 2004 |
| Colby Pridham | Hockey | 2010 | Intercollegiate Male - est . 2004 |
| Tom Nicholls | Powerlifting | 2010 | Masters - est. 2004 |
| Roy Main | Tennis | 2010 | Officials - 1989 |
| Churchill Arms Men’s | Soccer | 2010 | Team - est. 1975 |
| Kathy O’Rourke Rink | Curling | 2010 | Team - est. 1975 |
| John Diamond | Soccer | 2010 | Coach - est. 1976 |
| Mary Ellen McInnis | Figure Skating | 2010 | Administrator - est. 1975 |
| Howard Watts | Boxing | 2010 | President's - est. 1994 |
| Heather Moyse | Bobsleigh/Rugby | 2010 | Bill Halpenny - est. 1977 |
